It’s 5:20 on a Friday. The person who usually answers the phone has gone home. Someone calls your firm, gets voicemail, and hangs up. By Monday, you might have no idea they called. And they might have no idea when, or whether, they’ll hear back.
That’s where I’d start with AI in a small law firm. Give the caller a way to reach your team after hours without asking them to tell their whole story to a machine.
What I’d let it do
An AI phone assistant can identify itself, answer questions you’ve approved about office hours or location, and take a name, callback number, and preferred callback time. It can send that request to the person who covers intake. If no one is available, it should give the caller an honest expectation about when the office is staffed, not promise a callback by a time nobody agreed to.
If someone starts explaining what happened, wants legal advice, or mentions a hearing or deadline, that’s where I’d stop the script and use a handoff your firm has defined. The assistant doesn’t decide whether the matter is urgent, whether there’s a conflict, or whether the firm can take the case. It also shouldn’t collect documents or detailed facts before your intake team is ready. Your team should decide what it needs and where that information belongs.
Start with the calls you already miss
I’d try this on the after-hours line first. Before it touches a real call, have someone play a caller who won’t share their name, one who asks for legal advice, and one who says they have court tomorrow. Then test what happens when the transfer fails. If the caller winds up in a dead end, fix that before you go live.
Give one person ownership of the callback queue. Decide who can see the intake notes, what gets stored or recorded, and how long it’s kept. Review those choices against your firm’s confidentiality obligations before turning it on. The ABA’s guidance on generative AI and our AI policy guide for law firms are useful starting points.
After two weeks, look at how many callback requests actually made it to the right person and how quickly they were handled. I’d care a lot more about that than how natural the voice sounded.
If you want to see whether one part of your intake process is a good place to start, let’s talk through it.